SIEV-X - more truth to outChristian Kerr
17 May 2005
Political correspondent Christian Kerr writes:
The Federal government has been accused of knowing about the SIEV-X's fate, but doing nothing to rescue those aboard. A Senate inquiry has rejected these claims, but found it was extraordinary the incident passed undetected, given our extensive maritime surveillance designed to stop people smuggling.
SIEV-X remains a matter of controversy. The Daoed case is likely to do little to lessen this. Observers claim it will be a significant national security and civil liberties case. Refugee advocates argue that the government has been bringing people smuggling cases to court in less accessible locations, such as Brisbane, Darwin and Perth, to make it harder for senior journalists and Canberra corespondents to cover them.
The government has a relatively easy task in this trial - to prove that Daoed sold passages on SIEV-X. The main organiser of the voyage, Egyptian Abu Quassey, took good care not to take part in ticket selling transactions himself. He is currently serving a prison term in his native country after a local court found him guilty of homicide through negligence and aiding illegal immigration.
This may mean some of the bigger issues of the case are not mentioned. There have been accusations that Justice Minister Chris Ellison and the government have been at pains to talk up Daoed's role as Quassey's right hand man since his arrest and extradition to Australia in late 2003, making it easy to link him with the SIEV-X deaths.
Refugee advocates say this will mean that accusations surrounding the anti people smuggling program run in Indonesia by Immigration and the Australian federal police will not be properly tested in court - accusations including links between corrupt senior Indonesian police and "freelance" people smugglers.
The greatest question of them all - whether Australian officials knew an unsafe boat that was crammed with asylum seekers was sailing - may remain unanswered.
Source: Item no. 6 Crikey Squatters' Email Newsletter, 17 May 2005